Current:Home > reviewsClimate Scientists Take Their Closest Look Yet at the Warming Impact of Aviation Emissions -AssetBase
Climate Scientists Take Their Closest Look Yet at the Warming Impact of Aviation Emissions
View
Date:2025-04-23 09:12:43
An international team of prominent scientists has published what they say is the most comprehensive study to date calculating the complex climate impact of aviation emissions, reaffirming that contrail clouds produce more warming than carbon dioxide.
This kind of comprehensive analysis has only been performed a handful of times, starting with a report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) in 1999. The new study, looking at data from 2000 to 2018, notes that while the understanding of the impacts of aviation emissions “remains incomplete,” a series of new calculations considered “factors not previously applied in a common framework.”
“We wanted to produce a very high-quality benchmark assessment,” said David Lee, a climate scientist at Manchester Metropolitan University, who led the study and was also part of the IPCC assessment.
The study, which had been in the works since 2015, looked at both carbon dioxide and several types of “non-CO2” emissions in aviation. Carbon dioxide emissions are fairly well understood at this point, Lee said, but the impacts of non-CO2 emissions, which the study found account for about two-thirds of the net warming effect, are considerably harder to calculate.
The primary non-CO2 impact results from the emission of nitrogen oxides, water vapor and soot that can create heat-trapping contrail clouds. They form as emissions of hot gases and soot from aircraft engines activate water particles that freeze, producing the contrails, those straight, wispy white markings of a plane’s path through the sky.
Other non-CO2 emissions involve what the study calls “aviation aerosols”—small particles composed of black and organic carbon known as soot, sulfur and nitrogen compounds.
The team measured the “radiative forcing” of each item—a measure of how much potential it has to exert a change on the global climate.
Over the last decade the science around these emissions has improved drastically, Lee said, but he added that the better science doesn’t always mean the uncertainties will narrow. “We find out other stuff that we didn’t know before,” he said.
The climate impact of contrails has been a topic of contention in recent years. Contrails form in certain atmospheric conditions when the water vapors from airplane engines condense and freeze in the air—or when soot particles allow water in the atmosphere to condense around them—creating artificial clouds. The trails can become cirrus, or curling, clouds and hang around for hours, trapping atmospheric heat which contributes to global warming.
Of all the emissions measured, the researchers found these contrails to be the most impactful, but there’s a caveat.
“Contrail cirrus forcing is not as powerful as we used to think it was,” Lee said. The contrails appeared to be less than half as effective as previous estimates found. Carbon dioxide emissions, meanwhile, were the second most impactful, with roughly 60 percent as much effect on the climate as the vapor trails.
Measuring the effects of nitrogen oxides was tricky because they both eliminate atmospheric methane, which has a cooling effect, but create ozone which can act as a greenhouse gas. Between these two mechanisms, the researchers estimate that nitrogen oxides have a net warming effect that is about 30 percent as powerful as the vapor trails. The other emissions didn’t appear to have strong effects.
Even though contrails showed less effect than previous estimates, their impact is still considerable, given that warming from the contrails is greater than from carbon dioxide—and that the carbon dioxide emissions alone from the airline industry equal 2.4 percent of global CO2 emissions, according to a 2019 study by the International Council on Clean Transportation.
The magnitude of these emissions is also growing quickly. The International Civil Aviation Organization estimated pre-Covid-19 pandemic that demand for air travel would grow 4.3 percent annually for the next two decades.
“The airlines did not dispute that there was an impact of CO2 on the atmosphere,” said Annie Petsonk, the international counsel at the Environmental Defense Fund, who was not involved in the study. But until now, she said, they have claimed the science isn’t in on non-CO2 airline emissions.
This paper, in filling that knowledge gap, deprives airlines of excuses to avoid dealing with non-CO2 emissions, said Petsonk. While the European Union has voluntarily adopted stricter standards for aviation emissions, the United Nations body that governs international aviation standards recently adjusted an international agreement after airlines asked for reprieve, citing lost revenue because of Covid-19.
“The airlines are in the midst of a Covid crisis, which has hit them with a gut punch and they’re trying to get back on their feet. If they fail to put the climate crisis central to their rebuilding, then their efforts… will fail,” Petsonk said.
She said that getting aviation “on a trajectory for net zero climate” needs to be at the core of the industry’s recovery efforts from Covid-19 setbacks.
veryGood! (47)
Related
- The White House is cracking down on overdraft fees
- Raven-Symoné Mourns Death of Brother Blaize Pearman After Colon Cancer Battle
- Dak Prescott: NFL MVP front-runner? Cowboys QB squarely in conversation after beating Eagles
- The best time to see the Geminid meteor shower is this week. Here's how to view.
- Biden administration makes final diplomatic push for stability across a turbulent Mideast
- SmileDirectClub shuts down months after filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection
- Los Angeles Lakers to hang 'unique' NBA In-Season Tournament championship banner
- Teacher, CAIR cite discrimination from Maryland schools for pro-Palestinian phrase
- Juan Soto praise of Mets' future a tough sight for Yankees, but World Series goal remains
- Several seriously injured when construction site elevator crashes to the ground in Sweden
Ranking
- Average rate on 30
- After losing Houston mayor’s race, US Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee to seek reelection to Congress
- Special counsel Jack Smith asks Supreme Court to rule quickly on whether Trump can be prosecuted
- Steelers' Mike Tomlin wants George Pickens to show his frustrations in 'mature way'
- 'Malcolm in the Middle’ to return with new episodes featuring Frankie Muniz
- Watch: Florida bear goes Grinch, tramples and steals Christmas lawn decorations
- Tyreek Hill exits Dolphins’ game vs. Titans with an ankle injury
- Bengals QB Joe Burrow gifts suite tickets to family of backup Jake Browning
Recommendation
Federal hiring is about to get the Trump treatment
Israel continues attacks across Gaza as hopes for cease-fire fade
Rohingya Muslims in Indonesia struggle to find shelter. President says government will help for now
The US is restricting visas for nearly 300 Guatemalan lawmakers, others for ‘undermining democracy’
Nevada attorney general revives 2020 fake electors case
After losing Houston mayor’s race, US Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee to seek reelection to Congress
Turkey under pressure to seek return of Somalia president’s son involved in fatal traffic crash
The Excerpt podcast: Appeals court upholds Trump gag order in election interference case